Let’s face it: no one enjoys scraping food scraps into the trash or dealing with clogged sinks. That’s where a reliable garbage disposal swoops in to save the day, making kitchen cleanup a breeze. But with so many options out there, how do you find one that’s both efficient and won’t break the bank? If you’re hunting for the best garbage disposal for the money Good Housekeeping might recommend, you’ve come to the right place.
We’ve scoured the market to bring you a curated list of top-performing food waste disposers that offer incredible value without compromising on quality. From powerful grinding capabilities to easy installation and quiet operation, these units are designed to make your life easier and your kitchen cleaner. Plus, we’ve even thrown in some excellent companion products to keep your disposal in tip-top shape!
Let’s dive into our picks for the best garbage disposals that deliver serious bang for your buck.
1. InSinkErator Badger 5XP Garbage Disposal, Standard Series
The InSinkErator Badger 5XP is a solid workhorse, perfect for busy households looking for dependable performance without a hefty price tag. It strikes a fantastic balance between power and affordability, making it a strong contender for the best garbage disposal for the money. Its compact design is a real plus for fitting into tight under-sink spaces, and it’s known for its straightforward installation, especially if you’re upgrading from an existing InSinkErator unit. This model is all about reliable, everyday grinding power that gets the job done consistently.
Key Features:
– RELIABLE and EASY INSTALL: Compact, space-saving design fits existing InSinkErator hardware for quick and easy installation.
– DURABLE COMPONENTS: Features exclusive 3/4 hp Dura-Drive Induction Motor and long-lasting galvanized steel components.
– AMERICA’S DISPOSER BRAND: Trusted brand with a history of innovation.
– FASTER, CLEANER, SMARTER: Helps make kitchen cleanup fast and easy.
– A HISTORY OF INNOVATION FOR THE SINK: Invented garbage disposals in 1927.
Pros:
– Excellent value for its 3/4 HP motor.
– Known for reliability and durability.
– Easy to install, especially as a replacement.
– Compact size saves under-sink space.
Cons:
– Louder operation compared to higher-end models.
– Galvanized steel components are less corrosion-resistant than stainless steel.
User Impressions:
Customers frequently praise the Badger 5XP for its robust grinding power and its reputation for lasting years. Many appreciate the ease of installation, noting that it’s a great choice for a DIY project. While some mention the noise level, most agree it’s a small trade-off for the performance and price.
2. InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal, Standard Series 1/2
If you’re on a tighter budget or have lighter food waste grinding needs, the InSinkErator Badger 5 is an absolute gem. This 1/2 HP model provides reliable functionality and the same easy-install benefits as its 5XP sibling, but at an even more accessible price point. It’s a fantastic entry-level option that still carries the trusted InSinkErator name, offering a dependable solution for everyday food scraps without overspending. It’s perfect for smaller households or apartments where heavy-duty grinding isn’t a constant requirement.
Key Features:
– RELIABLE and EASY INSTALL: Compact, space-saving design, fits existing InSinkErator hardware.
– DURABLE COMPONENTS: Features 1/2 hp Dura-Drive Induction Motor and long-lasting galvanized steel components.
– AMERICA’S DISPOSER BRAND: Leading American disposer brand.
– FASTER, CLEANER, SMARTER: Simplifies meal prep and cleanup.
– A HISTORY OF INNOVATION FOR THE SINK: World’s largest manufacturer of disposals.
– Voltage: 120 V.
Pros:
– Very affordable and great for budget-conscious buyers.
– Easy to install, often a direct replacement for older models.
– Dependable for light to moderate food waste.
– Compact footprint.
Cons:
– 1/2 HP might struggle with tougher or larger food scraps.
– Can be somewhat noisy during operation.
– Galvanized steel components may be less durable over time than stainless steel.
User Impressions:
Users consistently highlight the Badger 5’s exceptional value and reliability for its price. It’s often recommended for single individuals, couples, or those with less demanding kitchen routines. Many are impressed by how long this “budget” model lasts, often exceeding their expectations.
3. Affresh Garbage Disposal Cleaner, Removes Odor-Causing Residues
Even the best garbage disposal for the money needs a little TLC to stay fresh and functional. That’s where the Affresh Garbage Disposal Cleaner comes in. This isn’t a disposal unit itself, but a vital companion for maintaining your investment. Its powerful citrus-scented foaming action actively cleans away odor-causing residues that build up in your disposal’s unseen areas. Regular use ensures your disposal runs cleanly and smells fresh, prolonging its life and maintaining its efficiency – a crucial part of getting good value.
Key Features:
– Powerful citrus-scented foaming action removes odor-causing residues.
– No.1 Recommended by Whirlpool and KitchenAid brands.
– Cleans chopper, internal cavity, and hose.
– Use monthly or as needed.
– Septic tank safe and U.S. EPA Safer Choice Certified.
– 9-month supply (9 tablets).
Pros:
– Effectively eliminates foul odors.
– Easy to use – just drop a tablet in.
– Septic-safe formula.
– Recommended by major appliance brands.
– Cleans internal components you can’t reach.
Cons:
– Requires regular monthly use for best results.
– Not a substitute for manual cleaning of the splash guard.
User Impressions:
Customers rave about how well Affresh tackles disposal odors, often describing a noticeable improvement after just one use. The convenience of simply dropping a tablet in is a major plus, and many appreciate that it’s safe for septic systems. It’s considered a must-have for keeping kitchen sinks smelling clean.
4. Bastion Garbage Disposal Cleaner and Deodorizer Drops
Another excellent way to keep your disposal system fresh and extend its lifespan is with Bastion Garbage Disposal Cleaner and Deodorizer Drops. Like Affresh, this product is a cleaner, not a disposal, but it’s key to maintaining the performance and hygiene of your unit. Bastion offers a generous 50-pack, providing excellent value for consistent odor control. Its D-Limonene active ingredient, derived from citrus, effectively breaks down fats and food particles, leaving a clean, lemon-zest scent. It’s an environmentally conscious choice that still delivers powerful cleaning.
Key Features:
– TOP QUALITY & BEST VALUE: 50-pack of premium lemon zest scented drops.
– SAVE MONEY & THE ENVIRONMENT: Compact packaging with more product, less plastic.
– SAFE & EFFECTIVE: Uses D-Limonene to break up smelly fats, oils, and food particles.
– EASY TO USE: Simple 3-step process.
– ZERO-RISK PURCHASE: Backed by a 30-Day Money Back Guarantee.
Pros:
– High quantity (50-pack) offers superior long-term value.
– Pleasant lemon zest scent.
– Environmentally friendly packaging and ingredients.
– Septic-safe.
– Very easy to use for regular maintenance.
Cons:
– Requires twice-per-week use for optimal results, which is more frequent than some alternatives.
– While effective, might require additional methods for extremely stubborn buildup.
User Impressions:
Users love the fresh scent and the sheer number of drops provided in the Bastion pack, finding it a cost-effective solution for ongoing disposal maintenance. The ease of use is frequently highlighted, making it a popular choice for quick and regular deodorizing. Many appreciate the brand’s commitment to sustainability.
5. InSinkErator Power .75HP, 3/4 HP Garbage Disposal, Power Series
Stepping up the game, the InSinkErator Power .75HP offers a significant upgrade in grinding performance and features, making it a strong contender if you’re looking for the best garbage disposal for the money with enhanced capabilities. This 3/4 HP model comes with 2-Stage MultiGrind Technology, meaning it grinds food scraps finer to prevent clogs – a huge plus for families that generate more waste. It’s also designed for easier DIY installation and operates with reduced noise compared to standard disposals, offering a more premium experience at a very competitive price.
Key Features:
– INSINKERATOR POWER .75HP 3/4 HP GARBAGE DISPOSAL: Includes EZ Connect Hardwire Adapter, flange, gaskets, wrenchette, and stopper.
– DESIGNED TO PREVENT CLOGS: 2-Stage MultiGrind Technology grinds food scraps finer; 3/4 HP Dura-Drive induction motor.
– DIY EZ CONNECT SINK GARBAGE DISPOSAL: USA-assembled with EZ Connect Hardwire Adapter, EZ Removable Dishwasher Inlet Plug, and Lift and Latch technology for easiest installation.
– REDUCED SOUND AND COMPACT: Operates with reduced noise levels; space-saving design.
– 6-YEAR LIMITED SERVICE WARRANTY: Backed by InSinkErator’s “We Come to You” warranty.
Pros:
– 2-Stage MultiGrind technology for finer grinding and fewer clogs.
– Reduced noise operation for a quieter kitchen.
– Easier DIY installation with EZ Connect features.
– Strong 3/4 HP Dura-Drive motor.
– Good 6-year warranty.
Cons:
– Power cord is sold separately.
– Still uses galvanized steel components, though durable.
User Impressions:
Reviewers are highly impressed with the Power .75HP’s ability to handle tough food waste with ease. The quieter operation is a frequently mentioned highlight, making it a preferred choice for open-concept kitchens. The simpler installation process also receives positive feedback, making it accessible for homeowners.
6. InSinkErator Badger 5 Garbage Disposal with Power Cord
This is essentially the same reliable InSinkErator Badger 5 we reviewed earlier, but with a crucial convenience factor: it comes with a power cord. This makes it an even more straightforward plug-and-play option for many homeowners, significantly simplifying the installation process. If you need a basic, dependable 1/2 HP disposal and want to avoid the extra step of purchasing and wiring a power cord, this version of the Badger 5 offers that added layer of convenience and immediate value. It truly emphasizes “for the money” by offering a complete package.
Key Features:
– RELIABLE and EASY INSTALL: Compact, space-saving design, fits existing InSinkErator hardware.
– DURABLE COMPONENTS: Features 1/2 hp Dura-Drive Induction Motor and long-lasting galvanized steel components.
– AMERICA’S DISPOSER BRAND: Leading American disposer brand.
– FASTER, CLEANER, SMARTER: Simplifies meal prep and cleanup.
– A HISTORY OF INNOVATION FOR THE SINK: World’s largest manufacturer of disposals.
– Includes power cord for added convenience.
Pros:
– Comes with a power cord, simplifying installation significantly.
– Very affordable for a dependable 1/2 HP model.
– Compact design saves space.
– Trusted InSinkErator reliability.
Cons:
– 1/2 HP may not be sufficient for heavy-duty grinding.
– Can be louder than higher-end models.
– Galvanized steel components are not as premium as stainless steel.
User Impressions:
Customers love the “ready to install” nature of this Badger 5 variant. The included power cord is a huge plus for DIY enthusiasts, saving time and an extra purchase. It’s consistently praised for being a sturdy and functional unit that perfectly meets the needs of average households without breaking the bank.
7. InSinkErator EVOLUTION 1HP 1 HP, Advanced Series Continuous
For those who demand the absolute best performance, quietest operation, and unmatched durability, the InSinkErator EVOLUTION 1HP Advanced Series is worth every penny. This 1 HP powerhouse, while a bit more of an investment upfront, delivers exceptional long-term value, making it a top pick for the best garbage disposal for the money in the premium category. Its 4-Stage MultiGrind technology handles the toughest food scraps with ease, and its Quietest SoundSeal technology ensures your kitchen remains peaceful. This model is a commitment to ultimate kitchen efficiency and tranquility.
Key Features:
– INSINKERATOR EVOLUTION 1 HP GARBAGE DISPOSAL: Includes EZ Connect Hardwire Adapter, flange, gaskets, bolts, wrenchette, and kitchen drain stopper.
– ADVANCED GRIND: 4-Stage MultiGrind technology for finest grinding of tough food scraps; 1 HP Dura-Drive induction motor and stainless steel grind components.
– DIY EZ CONNECT SINK GARBAGE DISPOSAL: USA-assembled with EZ Connect Hardwire Adapter, EZ Grip Handles, EZ Removable Dishwasher Inlet Plug, and Lift and Latch technology for easiest installation.
– QUIETEST AND COMPACT: Quietest SoundSeal technology for quietest disposal available; space-saving design.
– 10-YEAR LIMITED SERVICE WARRANTY: Backed by InSinkErator’s 10-Year “We Come to You” Limited Service Warranty.
Pros:
– Most powerful 1 HP motor for superior grinding.
– 4-Stage MultiGrind technology for the finest grind and clog prevention.
– Quietest operation thanks to SoundSeal technology.
– Durable stainless steel grind components.
– Excellent 10-year warranty provides peace of mind.
Cons:
– Higher upfront cost compared to other models.
– Power cord sold separately.
User Impressions:
Users are consistently amazed by the quietness and grinding power of the Evolution 1HP. Many describe it as virtually silent compared to their previous disposals, even when tackling challenging food waste like chicken bones or fibrous vegetables. The long warranty and stainless steel components also instill significant confidence in its durability and longevity.
Choosing Your Kitchen’s Best Friend
Finding the right garbage disposal for your home is about balancing power, features, noise level, and your budget. Whether you opt for a reliable workhorse like the InSinkErator Badger series, a step-up with MultiGrind technology, or the ultimate quiet power of the Evolution, any of these choices will significantly upgrade your kitchen experience. Don’t forget those essential cleaners to keep your new appliance running smoothly and smelling fresh!
Ultimately, choosing the best garbage disposal for the money for your home comes down to your specific needs and how much food waste your household typically generates. Invest wisely, and enjoy a cleaner, more efficient kitchen for years to come!
FAQ: All Your Garbage Disposal Questions Answered
Q1: What horsepower (HP) do I really need for my garbage disposal?
A: The ideal horsepower depends on your household size and typical food waste.
– 1/3 or 1/2 HP: Good for single people or couples with light waste (e.g., soft foods, small scraps).
– 3/4 HP: Best for average families (3-5 people) who dispose of a moderate amount of food waste, including tougher items like small bones and fibrous vegetables. This is often the sweet spot for value.
– 1 HP or more: Ideal for large families (5+ people), those who cook frequently, or heavy food waste users who need to grind tough scraps like larger bones or fruit rinds. These units are usually quieter and more durable.
Q2: Are garbage disposals safe for septic systems?
A: Generally, yes, but with caveats. Most modern garbage disposals are designed to be septic-safe. However, it’s crucial to use them in moderation and ensure your septic system is well-maintained and adequately sized for your household. Using septic-safe disposal cleaners (like Affresh or Bastion) also helps. Avoid putting excessive amounts of grease, coffee grounds, or tough, fibrous waste down the drain, as these can still pose problems for septic systems over time.
Q3: How do I clean my garbage disposal and eliminate odors?
A: Regular cleaning is key!
1. Ice and Salt/Vinegar: Grind a tray of ice cubes with a cup of rock salt or a cup of white vinegar. The ice helps dislodge grime, and the salt/vinegar helps scrub and deodorize.
2. Citrus Peels: Grind citrus peels (lemon, orange, lime) for a fresh scent and to help clean the grinding components.
3. Specialized Cleaners: Use tablets or drops like Affresh or Bastion weekly or monthly. They foam up and clean internal components.
4. Baking Soda & Vinegar: Pour 1/2 cup of baking soda down the drain, followed by a cup of white vinegar. Let it sit for 10-15 minutes, then flush with hot water.
Q4: What are the main differences between continuous feed and batch feed disposals?
A:
– Continuous Feed: This is the most common type. You turn it on, then continuously feed food scraps into the drain while it’s running. It’s convenient for larger amounts of waste. All the InSinkErator disposals reviewed here are continuous feed.
– Batch Feed: Food scraps are loaded into the disposal, and then the cover (which also acts as a safety switch) is put in place to activate the unit. It only runs one “batch” at a time. They are often considered safer but less convenient for continuous use.
Q5: What should I absolutely NOT put down a garbage disposal?
A: To prevent clogs and extend the life of your disposal, avoid these:
– Grease, Oil, Fat: They solidify and cling to pipes.
– Fibrous Vegetables: Celery, corn husks, artichokes, onion skins – their fibers can tangle around components.
– Coffee Grounds: They accumulate and create sludge.
– Potato Peels: Starchy and can create a thick paste.
– Bones: Small chicken bones might be okay for high-HP units, but larger bones are a no-go.
– Fruit Pits & Hard Shells: Avocado pits, peach pits, seafood shells are too hard.
– Pasta & Rice: They expand with water and can cause clogs.
– Non-Food Items: Obviously, no plastic, metal, glass, paper, or cleaning rags.
Q6: How long do garbage disposals typically last?
A: The lifespan of a garbage disposal can vary greatly depending on its quality, usage, and maintenance. On average, a good quality garbage disposal can last anywhere from 8 to 15 years. Higher-end models with stainless steel components and more powerful motors (like the InSinkErator Evolution series) tend to last longer. Regular cleaning and avoiding prohibited items can significantly extend its life.
Q7: Is it easy to install a garbage disposal myself?
A: For many homeowners with basic plumbing knowledge, installing a garbage disposal can be a DIY project, especially if you’re replacing an existing unit with a similar model (like an InSinkErator replacing another InSinkErator). Modern disposals often feature “EZ Connect” or “Quick-Lock” systems designed for easier installation. However, if you’re uncomfortable with electrical wiring, working with plumbing, or don’t have existing wiring under your sink, it’s always best to hire a licensed plumber or electrician to ensure a safe and proper installation.